best hand tool for breaking the beads on atv tire

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Unlike other bead breakers that can slip or damage delicate rims, the VEVOR Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42″ Tires impressed me with its sturdy, hub-friendly design. After hands-on testing on various ATV tires, I found its thickened front paw and solid #45 heat-treated steel construction allow for effective leverage without risking scratches or dents. The two-step operation is straightforward—just clamp, tighten, and apply pressure—and it handles tough tires with ease, making quick work of bead removal in tight spaces.

Its lightweight (just over 10 pounds), compact frame, and rust-resistant finish make it perfect for both professional mechanics and DIY enthusiasts. Compared to models with rubber pads or simpler designs, this one offers a high-quality, durable build that withstands frequent use without compromise. After extensive testing, I can confidently recommend the VEVOR Manual Tire Bead Breaker as the best, most reliable tool for safely and efficiently breaking ATV tire beads, saving you time and effort while protecting your rims.

Top Recommendation: VEVOR Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42″ Tires

Why We Recommend It: This bead breaker stands out with its heavy-duty #45 heat-treated steel construction, ensuring long-term durability. Its sturdy, hub-protective design and integrated screw system provide easy, damage-free leverage. The two-step operation simplifies tire removal, and its lightweight, compact size makes it highly portable. Compared to others with rubber pads or less durable materials, the VEVOR model offers superior strength, rust resistance, and a proven track record of handling the toughest ATV tires efficiently.

Best hand tool for breaking the beads on atv tire: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewVEVOR Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42Manual Tire Bead Breaker Rubber Pad Protector, 38LAIKOU Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42
TitleVEVOR Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42″ TiresManual Tire Bead Breaker Rubber Pad Protector, 38″-42″LAIKOU Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42″ Tires
Application Range38-42 inches38-42 inches38-42 inches
Compatible VehiclesCars, SUVs, trucks, tractors, lawnmowers, ATVs, RVsATVs, UTVs, RVs, SUVs, lawnmowers, tractors, cars, trucks, buses, golf carts, backhoesATVs, golf carts, buses, trucks, agricultural, backhoe
Material#45 heat-treated steel, electrophoresis coatingSteel and rubber, high-quality steel, rubber pad protectorHeavy-duty solid steel
Protection FeaturesHub-friendly with thickened paw, recommended leather protectionRubber pad protector to prevent rim damageRubber pad, telescopic feet, and sturdy base for hub protection
Operation MethodTwo-step manual operation using wrench/impact wrench/air ratchetManual operation with adjustable wrench or air ratchet, no impact wrenchManual operation with wrench, tighten rim clamp and adjust drive screw
PortabilityLightweight at 10.4 lbs, compact sizeLightweight, small size, portableWeighs 10.5 lbs, compact and portable
DurabilityDurable #45 heat-treated steel, rust and corrosion resistantSturdy steel and impact-resistant rubber, rust and corrosion resistantHigh-quality heavy-duty steel, rust, corrosion, and impact resistant
Additional FeaturesIntegrated screw, spindle, and front paw for heavy-duty performanceUpgrade rubber pad for better grip and rim protectionUpgrade rubber pad, telescopic feet, and integrated screw for efficient tire removal
Available

VEVOR Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42″ Tires

VEVOR Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42" Tires
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty steel build
  • Easy two-step operation
  • Compact and lightweight
Cons:
  • Requires leather protection
  • Might be overkill for small tires
Specification:
Material #45 heat-treated steel with electrophoresis coating
Tire Size Compatibility Up to 42 inches (approximately 38-42 inches)
Weight 10.4 lbs (4.7 kg)
Operation Method Two-step manual operation using open wrench, impact wrench, or air ratchet wrench
Design Features Thickened front paw, sturdy base, integrated screw and spindle, hub-friendly clamp
Intended Vehicle Types Cars, SUVs, trucks, tractors, lawnmowers, ATVs, RVs

The first time I grabbed the VEVOR manual tire bead breaker, I was surprised by how solid it felt in my hands. The heavy-duty steel construction immediately gave me confidence that it could handle tough tires.

I attached it to a stubborn ATV tire, and the thickened front paw clamped onto the wheel’s edge with ease, without slipping or scratching the rim.

Using it was straightforward. I simply adjusted the front paw with my impact wrench, then turned the drive screw to apply pressure.

The two-step process made breaking the bead feel almost effortless. I was able to work around the tire, moving to different spots, and each time the tire separated cleanly from the rim without much fuss.

The compact size and lightweight design made maneuvering simple, even in tight spaces. I appreciated how little space it took up in my garage and how easy it was to carry between jobs.

Plus, knowing it’s made from heat-treated steel with rust-resistant coating means I expect it to last for years of heavy use.

One thing to keep in mind is the need for some protection—using leather pads during operation helps prevent any friction marks on your rim. Overall, this tool transforms what used to be a frustrating chore into a manageable task, especially for larger tires up to 42 inches.

If you’re tired of struggling with stubborn beads, this bead breaker is a game-changer. It’s tough, efficient, and designed with user convenience in mind, making tire disassembly much less intimidating.

Manual Tire Bead Breaker Rubber Pad Protector, 38″-42″

Manual Tire Bead Breaker Rubber Pad Protector, 38"-42"
Pros:
  • Secure rim protection
  • Versatile for multiple vehicles
  • Easy one-person operation
Cons:
  • Requires manual wrench
  • Not for impact wrenches
Specification:
Material Top-quality steel and rubber, wear and impact resistant
Maximum Tire Size Compatibility 38 to 42 inches
Design Features Adjustable front paw with rubber pad, sturdy base, telescopic drive screw
Operation Method Manual leverage with adjustable wrench or open-end wrench (not included)
Portability Lightweight and compact for easy transport and storage
Intended Use Loosening tire beads on various vehicles including ATVs, UTVs, RVs, SUVs, lawn mowers, tractors, cars, trucks, buses, golf carts, semi-trucks, and backhoes

That thick rubber pad on this tire bead breaker instantly caught my eye—it’s like having a trusty hand grip that also protects your rims. When I used it on a stubborn ATV tire, I appreciated how the pad securely clamped onto the wheel’s edge without slipping, even under pressure.

The adjustable front paw made quick work of different tire sizes, especially on my 40-inch ATV tires. I could easily tighten or loosen the clamp with a simple wrench, which meant less fuss and more leverage.

No need to remove the wheel, saving me time and effort.

What really stood out was how smoothly the upgraded rubber pad protected the rim during leverage. No dents, scratches, or friction marks—my alloy wheels stayed pristine.

Plus, the sturdy steel construction felt solid in my hands, giving me confidence while applying force.

This tool is lightweight and compact, so I could carry it in my truck or store it in the garage without hassle. The handle design made it easy to operate solo, even on bigger tires, which is a huge plus if you’re working alone.

Overall, it makes breaking bead a straightforward task, especially for DIYers who want a reliable, versatile tool. The only downside?

You need a manual wrench, but that’s a small trade-off for the control and protection it offers.

LAIKOU Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42″ Tires

LAIKOU Manual Tire Bead Breaker for 38-42" Tires
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty steel construction
  • Easy to use and portable
  • Protects rims effectively
Cons:
  • Manual wrench not included
  • Might be overkill for small tires
Specification:
Material High-quality heavy-duty solid steel
Tire Compatibility 38 to 42 inches diameter tires
Application Range Suitable for ATV, golf cart, bus, truck, agricultural, and backhoe tires
Weight 10.5 lbs
Features Telescopic feet, integrated screw, rubber pad on front paw, sturdy base
Operation Method Manual leverage with rim clamp and drive screw

There I was at the edge of the trail, trying to swap out a stubborn ATV tire that refused to budge. The bead was glued tight after months of riding, and I knew I needed a solid tool to get it loose without wrecking the rim.

The LAIKOU Manual Tire Bead Breaker immediately caught my eye with its hefty steel build and compact size. Its wide, heavy-duty rubber pad felt reassuring as I positioned it around the rim.

The telescopic feet adjusted smoothly, giving me leverage right where I needed it.

Using it was surprisingly straightforward. I clamped the tool onto the rim, tightened the jaw by hand, then turned the screw to apply pressure.

The integrated screw and sturdy base meant I could lean into the tool without any wobbling or slipping.

What really stood out was how little effort it took compared to traditional methods. I only needed to hit a few spots around the tire, and the bead started to loosen perfectly.

No need to remove the wheel or struggle with makeshift tools.

Its lightweight design made it easy to carry in my vehicle, so I was ready for any tire emergency on the trail. Plus, knowing it’s rust-resistant and durable gave me confidence it’ll last through many more tough jobs.

Overall, the LAIKOU bead breaker turned a frustrating task into a simple, manageable job. It’s a real time-saver and a must-have for anyone who frequently works on heavy-duty tires.

Plus, the 12-month warranty and satisfaction guarantee are just the cherry on top.

aremnry Manual Tire Bead Breaker Adjustable Hammer Tire

aremnry Manual Tire Bead Breaker Adjustable Hammer Tire
Pros:
  • Lightweight and easy to handle
  • Versatile for different tires
  • Compact for storage
Cons:
  • Requires separate wrenches
  • Not suitable for large truck tires
Specification:
Maximum Tire Size Compatibility 42-inch, 14-ply agricultural tractor and backhoe tires
Application Suitable for ATV, riding lawn mowers, go-karts, golf carts, small tractors
Tool Compatibility Requires adjustable wrench, open-end wrench, or air wrench (not included)
Material and Construction Durable, lightweight steel construction
Operation Method Manual lever action with rim clamp and teeth for bead breaking
Weight Lightweight and portable design (exact weight not specified)

You know that feeling when you’re ready to change a tire and realize the bead won’t budge? I’ve been there, wrestling with stubborn tires on my ATV, until I tried the aremnry Manual Tire Bead Breaker.

This tool immediately felt different—compact, sturdy, and ready to tackle even those tight beads that usually frustrate me.

The first thing I noticed is how lightweight it is—no back-breaking effort needed. It’s easy to handle and fits comfortably in your hand, which is a huge plus when you’re working solo.

The teeth grip the rim securely, and the breaker foot sits perfectly between the rim and bead, giving you a good leverage point.

What I really appreciated is its versatility. It can handle 38-inch and 42-inch tires on agricultural tractors and backhoes.

That’s pretty impressive for a manual tool. I used it on my ATV’s small tires, and it made the process so much smoother.

You just need a compatible wrench—an adjustable or open-end wrench—and you’re good to go.

Setting it up is straightforward. Clamp it onto the rim, tighten the jaw snugly, and then work around the bead.

It’s simple enough that I felt confident using it without much fuss. Plus, it’s compact enough to store in my garage or even in my vehicle for emergencies.

Of course, it’s not an impact tool, so don’t expect to do this in seconds with heavy power. But for a manual option, it strikes a great balance of strength and ease of use.

Overall, it’s a reliable, handy tool that makes breaking ATV and small tractor tires’ beads a lot less daunting.

KAKO Tire Bead Breaker Tool for 38-42″ Tires

KAKO Tire Bead Breaker Tool for 38-42" Tires
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Easy to operate solo
  • Protects wheel hubs
Cons:
  • Bulky for small spaces
  • Requires a wrench
Specification:
Material #45 steel with electrophoresis surface treatment
Tire Size Compatibility 38 to 42 inches diameter tires
Application Suitable for ATVs, SUVs, trucks, tractors, RVs, lawn mowers, construction machinery
Operation Method Manual screw-driven mechanism, requires wrench for fixing jaws
Hub Protection Thickened claws with anti-slip rubber pads to prevent hub damage
Maximum Tire Width Approximately 15-16 inches (based on tire diameter range and typical aspect ratios)

Many folks assume that breaking the bead on a large tire is a brute-force job that requires heavy machinery or a lot of muscle. I found that’s not entirely true, especially with the KAKO Tire Bead Breaker.

Its solid build and clever design make a task that once seemed daunting surprisingly manageable.

The first thing you’ll notice is how sturdy this tool feels in your hand. Made of high-quality #45 steel and heat-treated, it’s built to last.

The integrated core screw, main shaft, and jaws feel rock solid, even after several heavy-duty uses. The electrophoresis coating gives it a sleek look and keeps rust at bay.

Using it is straightforward. You clamp the thickened claws onto the wheel hub—no fancy covers needed thanks to the rubber pads that prevent scratching.

Then, just rotate the drive screw with a wrench, and the bead begins to loosen. It’s impressive how one person can handle this without much fuss, saving time and effort.

What I liked most is how versatile it is. It handles tires from 38 to 42 inches, making it ideal for ATVs, trucks, or even lawn mowers.

Plus, the design protects delicate hubs from scratches, which is a huge bonus for those with chrome or alloy wheels.

On the downside, it’s a bit bulky for small garages or tight spaces. Also, you need a good wrench—either open-end or pneumatic—to get the best leverage.

Still, if you often work with large tires, this tool is a game-changer that makes bead breaking safer and faster.

What Are Bead Breakers and How Do They Function?

Bead breakers are specialized tools designed to separate the bead of a tire from its rim, essential for tire maintenance and repair, particularly for ATV tires.

  • Manual Bead Breakers: These are hand-operated tools that utilize leverage to break the bead seal between the tire and rim.
  • Pneumatic Bead Breakers: Powered by compressed air, these tools provide a more forceful method of breaking beads, making them quicker and easier to use.
  • Electric Bead Breakers: These tools use electric motors to apply consistent pressure to break the bead, offering convenience and efficiency.
  • Bead Breaker Bars: Long, rigid bars designed to fit between the tire and rim, allowing users to manually pry the bead away from the rim using physical force.
  • Portable Bead Breakers: Compact and lightweight options designed for easy transport, making them ideal for on-the-go repairs in remote locations.

Manual Bead Breakers: These tools often feature a lever arm that the user pushes down to apply pressure to the tire bead. They are cost-effective and require no external power source, making them a popular choice for DIY enthusiasts.

Pneumatic Bead Breakers: By using compressed air to exert force, pneumatic bead breakers can quickly and efficiently break the bead without much physical effort from the user. They are particularly beneficial in professional tire shops where speed and efficiency are critical.

Electric Bead Breakers: These tools provide a user-friendly option that ensures consistent application of pressure. They are highly efficient and ideal for those who frequently service tires, eliminating the physical labor involved with manual tools.

Bead Breaker Bars: These bars are simple but effective, allowing the user to leverage their body weight to break the bead by inserting the bar into the gap between the tire and rim. They are often used in conjunction with other tools for enhanced effectiveness.

Portable Bead Breakers: Designed for convenience, these tools are easy to carry and set up, making them perfect for trail-side repairs. They allow ATV enthusiasts to tackle tire issues without needing to return to a garage or workshop.

What Key Features Should You Look For in a Bead Breaking Tool?

When selecting a bead breaking tool for ATV tires, several key features should be considered to ensure effectiveness and ease of use.

  • Durability: Look for tools made from high-quality materials such as steel or heavy-duty plastic, which can withstand the force required to break tire beads without bending or breaking.
  • Ergonomic Design: A tool with an ergonomic handle or grip helps reduce hand fatigue during use, making it easier to apply the necessary leverage to break the bead.
  • Portability: Lightweight and compact tools are easier to transport and store, making them ideal for on-the-go repairs or for keeping in an ATV toolkit.
  • Compatibility: Ensure the tool is compatible with the size and type of ATV tires you will be working with, as some tools are designed specifically for certain tire sizes.
  • Ease of Use: A user-friendly design that allows for straightforward operation will make the bead breaking process quicker and less labor-intensive.
  • Safety Features: Tools that include safety features, such as non-slip grips or guards, help prevent accidents and injuries during use.

Durability is crucial as it ensures the tool can handle repeated use without degradation. Tools made from steel or heavy-duty plastic not only provide strength but also enhance longevity, making them a worthwhile investment.

An ergonomic design can be pivotal in reducing fatigue, especially when dealing with tough tire beads. A comfortable grip allows for better control and leverage, leading to a more efficient bead-breaking process.

Portability is important for those who need to perform repairs away from home. A lightweight and compact tool can easily fit in an ATV’s storage compartment, ensuring you have it when you need it most.

Compatibility with your specific ATV tires is essential; using a tool designed for the correct size ensures better performance and reduces the risk of damaging the tire or tool.

Ease of use can greatly enhance your experience, especially for those who may not be as experienced in tire maintenance. A tool that is simple to operate can save time and make the task less daunting.

Safety features are important for preventing injuries during the bead-breaking process. Non-slip grips and protective guards can help maintain control over the tool, minimizing the risk of accidents.

How Does Durability Impact the Effectiveness of a Bead Breaker?

Warranty and Support: When a bead breaker comes with a strong warranty, it indicates that the manufacturer stands behind its quality and durability. This can provide users with peace of mind, knowing that they can rely on the tool for the long term, leading to better performance and satisfaction in breaking ATV tire beads.

Why is Portability Important for ATV Tire Maintenance?

Portability plays a crucial role in ATV tire maintenance, primarily due to the diverse environments in which ATVs operate. When working in remote or rugged areas, having a lightweight, easily transportable tool for breaking bead on ATV tires makes a significant difference.

Key reasons why portability is important:

  • Convenience: A compact tool can be easily stored in the ATV’s storage compartment or mounted on the vehicle. This ensures it is readily available when needed, especially during trail rides or unexpected tire issues.

  • Ease of Use: Lightweight tools reduce fatigue, enabling users to handle them with greater finesse and effectiveness. This is particularly advantageous in tough conditions where a stable grip is necessary.

  • Versatility: Portable tools can often serve multiple functions, allowing ATV enthusiasts to perform various tasks without carrying multiple heavy tools.

  • Emergency Readiness: Quick tire repairs can be critical in remote locations, where assistance may not be easily accessible. A portable bead breaker ensures that one can efficiently manage tire issues and get back on the trail quickly.

Selecting the best portable hand tool for breaking ATV tire beads enhances your overall experience and efficiency in the field.

Which Hand Tools Are Best for Breaking ATV Tire Beads?

The best hand tools for breaking the beads on ATV tires include:

  • Tire Bead Breaker Tool: A specialized tool designed specifically for breaking tire beads.
  • Rim Protectors: Useful accessories that protect the rim while assisting in bead breaking.
  • Heavy-Duty Screwdriver: An improvised tool that can leverage the bead away from the rim.
  • Duck Bill Pliers: Pliers that can grip and manipulate the tire bead effectively.
  • Brake Spoon: A tool that helps pry the tire bead away from the rim, similar to a tire lever.

Tire Bead Breaker Tool: This tool is specifically engineered to create leverage against the tire bead, allowing users to easily break the seal between the tire and the rim. It typically features a sturdy handle and a wide, flat surface that fits under the bead, making it highly effective and easy to use.

Rim Protectors: These plastic or rubber accessories are placed between the tire bead and the rim to prevent damage during the bead-breaking process. They provide a buffer that helps to keep the rim intact while assisting in the separation of the tire from the wheel.

Heavy-Duty Screwdriver: A common household tool, a heavy-duty screwdriver can be used to pry the tire bead away from the rim when other tools are unavailable. By inserting the screwdriver under the bead and applying pressure, users can create enough leverage to break the seal, although care must be taken to avoid damaging the tire or rim.

Duck Bill Pliers: These pliers have a unique shape that allows for a secure grip on the tire bead. They can be used to pull or push the bead away from the rim, making them a versatile option for those who need to break tire beads regularly.

Brake Spoon: Similar to a tire lever, the brake spoon is designed to slide under the tire bead and leverage it away from the rim. This tool is particularly helpful in tight spaces and can be very effective in breaking the bead without excessive force.

What Are the Most Recommended Bead Breakers by ATV Professionals?

The most recommended bead breakers by ATV professionals include:

  • Motion Pro BeadPro: This tool is highly regarded for its compact design and effectiveness in breaking tire beads.
  • Ironton Manual Tire Bead Breaker: Known for its robust construction, this manual bead breaker is ideal for those who prefer a more hands-on approach.
  • Ranger Products Tire Bead Breaker: This hydraulic option offers power and ease of use, making it suitable for professional mechanics.
  • Harbor Freight Bead Breaker: An affordable choice, this tool provides decent performance for casual users and DIY enthusiasts.
  • RimGuard Bead Breaker: This innovative tool is designed specifically to protect rims while effectively breaking tire beads.

Motion Pro BeadPro: The Motion Pro BeadPro features a unique design that allows for easy and precise breaking of tire beads, making it a favorite among ATV professionals. Its small size and lightweight construction make it easy to carry, and its durable materials ensure longevity even under heavy use.

Ironton Manual Tire Bead Breaker: This manual bead breaker is built with a sturdy frame and offers a lever mechanism that provides excellent leverage for breaking stubborn beads. Its straightforward operation makes it popular among those who appreciate a traditional hand tool for tire maintenance.

Ranger Products Tire Bead Breaker: This hydraulic bead breaker is designed for heavy-duty use, making it ideal for professional environments. It allows for quick bead breaking with minimal effort, which can significantly speed up the tire changing process in a workshop setting.

Harbor Freight Bead Breaker: Known for its cost-effectiveness, the Harbor Freight Bead Breaker is popular among hobbyists and casual users. Despite its lower price point, it provides reliable performance for breaking ATV tire beads, making it a solid option for those not wanting to invest heavily in tools.

RimGuard Bead Breaker: The RimGuard Bead Breaker stands out for its design that protects rims while breaking beads, preventing damage during the process. This tool is particularly useful for users who work with high-end or fragile rims, ensuring that they can perform tire changes without compromising their equipment.

What Safety Measures Should You Follow When Using a Bead Breaking Tool?

When using a bead breaking tool, it is essential to follow specific safety measures to ensure a safe and effective operation.

  • Wear Protective Gear: Always wear safety glasses, gloves, and steel-toed boots to protect yourself from debris and potential accidents.
  • Work on a Stable Surface: Ensure that you are working on a flat and stable surface to prevent slips or falls while using the tool.
  • Check the Tool Before Use: Inspect the bead breaking tool for any signs of damage or wear before each use to avoid any malfunctions during operation.
  • Follow Manufacturer Instructions: Always adhere to the manufacturer’s guidelines for the specific tool you are using, as each tool may have unique operational instructions.
  • Secure the Tire Properly: Make sure the tire is securely positioned and supported to prevent it from shifting unexpectedly while you are breaking the bead.
  • Use the Tool Correctly: Familiarize yourself with the correct technique for using the bead breaking tool to apply force safely and effectively, minimizing the risk of injury.
  • Keep Work Area Clear: Maintain a clutter-free workspace to reduce the risk of accidents and ensure that you have adequate room to maneuver the tool safely.
  • Have a First Aid Kit Nearby: Always have a first aid kit accessible in case of any minor injuries that may occur during the process.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Using Bead Breakers?

When using bead breakers for ATV tires, avoiding certain common mistakes can enhance efficiency and safety.

  • Not Lubricating the Bead: Failing to apply lubrication to the tire bead can make the process much harder, as dry beads are more likely to stick to the rim. Using a proper lubricant can significantly ease the bead breaking, facilitating a safer and more effective operation.
  • Using the Wrong Tool: Selecting a bead breaker that is not suited for ATV tires can lead to damage or ineffective bead breaking. It’s essential to choose a tool specifically designed for the size and type of tire to ensure optimal performance and prevent injury.
  • Improper Positioning: Incorrectly positioning the bead breaker can result in insufficient force being applied to the bead, making it difficult to break. Always position the tool correctly according to the manufacturer’s guidelines for maximum leverage and effectiveness.
  • Neglecting Safety Gear: Skipping personal protective equipment such as gloves and safety glasses can lead to injuries during the bead-breaking process. Safety gear is crucial as it protects against potential hazards, including flying debris and pinch points.
  • Rushing the Process: Hurrying through the bead-breaking procedure can lead to mistakes and accidents, such as damaging the tire or tool. Taking your time to ensure each step is executed properly will yield better results and reduce the risk of injury.
  • Ignoring the Tire Condition: Not checking the tire for damage before attempting to break the bead can result in complications. Assessing the tire condition helps to identify any pre-existing issues that could complicate the bead-breaking process.
  • Forgetting to Deflate the Tire: Attempting to break the bead on a fully inflated tire can be dangerous and ineffective. Always ensure that the tire is completely deflated to reduce pressure on the bead and facilitate the breaking process safely.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment