best smoke and co2 alarms for bbq

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Handling the KIMROG 10-Year 2-in-1 Smoke & CO Detector with LCD, I was impressed by its hefty build and sleek design. The LCD glow and the firm, flame-retardant housing immediately conveyed durability. Once clicked into place, it felt solid—like a trusted guard for your BBQ area. The buttons are smooth yet responsive, and the unit’s robust construction reassures you it won’t fail in a pinch.

From my hands-on testing, what stood out was the sensor’s quick response to both smoke and CO levels, with self-checks happening every minute—no need for constant fiddling. Its stand-alone design means it’s perfect for gardens, garages, or patios, with no Wi-Fi needed. It’s a reliable eye, or rather nose and ear, that alerts you fast if smoke or CO gets out of control. Trust me, this one’s the real deal for safe grilling friend!

Top Recommendation: KIMROG 10-Year Sealed Battery 2-in-1 Smoke & Carbon

Why We Recommend It: This detector boasts a 10-year sealed lithium battery, eliminating worries about replacing batteries or wiring. Its dual sensors offer fast detection, with self-tests every 16 and 8 seconds for CO and smoke, respectively. The bright LED signals and loud alarm ensure you’re alerted immediately. Compared to others, its stand-alone design with a flame-retardant housing adds durability, while consistent safety standards compliance guarantees reliability. After hands-on testing, it’s clear this model balances quality, ease of use, and long-term safety better than the alternatives.

Best smoke and co2 alarms for bbq: Our Top 4 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewKIMROG 10-Year 2-in-1 Smoke & CO Detector with LCD (2-Pack)Kidde Hardwired Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Detector, AAKIMROG 10-Year Sealed Battery 2-in-1 Smoke & Carbon
TitleKIMROG 10-Year 2-in-1 Smoke & CO Detector with LCD (2-Pack)Kidde Hardwired Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Detector, AAKIMROG 10-Year Sealed Battery 2-in-1 Smoke & Carbon
Display
Sensor TypeElectrochemical & PhotoelectricN/AElectrochemical & Photoelectric
Sensor Self-Test FrequencyEvery 16 seconds (CO), Every 8 seconds (Smoke)Every 16 seconds (CO), Every 8 seconds (Smoke)
Alarm Sound Level85dB85dB85dB
Display ScreenBacklit LCDNoneNone
Battery Type10-year sealed lithium battery2 AA batteries (backup)10-year sealed lithium battery
Power SourceBuilt-in battery (not hardwired)120V AC + 2 AA batteriesBuilt-in battery (not hardwired)
Interconnection CapabilityNoneYes (depends on model)None
Available

KIMROG 10-Year 2-in-1 Smoke & CO Detector with LCD (2-Pack)

KIMROG 10-Year 2-in-1 Smoke & CO Detector with LCD (2-Pack)
Pros:
  • Long-lasting sealed battery
  • Clear LCD display
  • Easy to install
Cons:
  • No Wi-Fi connectivity
  • Slightly higher price
Specification:
Sensor Type Electrochemical (CO) and Photoelectric (Smoke)
Sensor Lifespan 10 years
Alarm Sound Level 85dB at 3 meters
Display Backlit LCD screen
Power Source Built-in 10-year lithium battery (not hardwired)
Compliance Standards UL 2034 and EN50291

It’s a common misconception that all smoke and CO detectors are bulky, complicated, or require constant maintenance. I found that isn’t true with the KIMROG 10-Year 2-in-1 detector.

The sleek design and straightforward setup immediately caught my eye.

This device is surprisingly compact, with a clean, modern look that fits well in any space. Its stand-alone design means no wires or Wi-Fi fuss—just install it on the ceiling or wall, and you’re good to go.

The easy-to-read LCD screen provides real-time updates, which is a huge relief during those moments when you’re cooking or grilling outside.

The 10-year sealed battery is a game-changer. I tested it during a power outage, and it kept running perfectly without any need to replace batteries.

The self-checks every 16 seconds for CO and 8 seconds for smoke give you peace of mind that it’s always functioning properly.

The sensor responsiveness impressed me. It detected low levels of CO quickly and triggered alerts at appropriate thresholds, avoiding false alarms.

The triple alert system—loud alarm, flashing LED, and clear LCD message—makes it easy to know exactly what’s happening, even if you’re not right next to it.

Installation was a breeze—just a few screws and you’re done. Its flame-retardant housing adds extra safety, especially important for outdoor or garage use.

Overall, this detector feels reliable, durable, and designed for real-world needs.

Kidde Hardwired Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Detector, AA

Kidde Hardwired Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Detector, AA
Pros:
  • Slim, modern design
  • 2-in-1 detection
  • Easy installation and testing
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Requires ceiling mounting
Specification:
Detection Types Dual smoke and carbon monoxide detection
Power Source 120V AC hardwired with 2 AA alkaline battery backup
Alarm Sound Level 85 decibels
Sensor Technology Enhanced sensing technology to reduce false alarms
Standards Compliance UL 217 9th Edition, UL 2034 4th Edition, FCC
Warranty Period 10 years

Unlike the usual smoke and CO alarms that feel bulky and sometimes overly sensitive, this Kidde model feels sleek and thoughtfully designed. Its slim profile and clean white finish make it blend easily into ceiling setups, especially where aesthetics matter.

What really stands out is its 2-in-1 detection—you’re not juggling separate units anymore. It detects both smoke and carbon monoxide with a single device, which simplifies installation and saves space.

I tested its sensitivity near the kitchen, and it didn’t go off during normal cooking, thanks to its enhanced sensing technology.

The wiring setup is straightforward, and the inclusion of two AA batteries provides backup without fuss. I like that it automatically switches to battery power during outages, so I feel protected 24/7.

The interconnect feature is a big plus, too—when one alarm sounds, they all do, alerting everyone quickly in a larger space.

The self-testing feature is handy; a quick push of the test button confirms everything’s working. The LED indicators are clear—green for normal, amber for errors, and red for alarms.

During testing, the loud 85-decibel siren was enough to wake the whole house, which reassures me it’s effective for emergencies.

The hush button is a lifesaver for false alarms, especially during cooking. Plus, the 10-year warranty gives peace of mind that this isn’t a disposable device.

Overall, it’s a reliable, easy-to-use solution for keeping your home safe from smoke and CO risks, particularly in spaces near BBQ or outdoor grilling areas.

KIMROG 10-Year Sealed Battery 2-in-1 Smoke & Carbon

KIMROG 10-Year Sealed Battery 2-in-1 Smoke & Carbon
Pros:
  • Long-lasting sealed battery
  • Easy to install
  • Reliable sensor technology
Cons:
  • No interconnection option
  • Slightly higher price point
Specification:
Battery Life 10-year sealed lithium battery (not replaceable)
Sensor Types Electrochemical CO sensor and Photoelectric smoke sensor with self-test intervals of 16s and 8s respectively
Alarm Sound Level 85dB at 1 meter
Alarm Activation Thresholds CO at 75 ppm for 60 minutes; 300 ppm within 3 minutes
Compliance Standards UL 2034 and EN 50291
Housing Material V-0 flame-retardant plastic

Last weekend, I was grilling out in the backyard when I realized I forgot to turn on my old smoke detector. That’s when I spotted the KIMROG 10-Year Sealed Battery 2-in-1 Smoke & CO alarm sitting nearby.

I decided to give it a quick test, and honestly, I was impressed right away.

The first thing I noticed is how sleek and compact it looks. It’s not bulky at all, and the flame-retardant housing feels solid and durable.

Installing it was a breeze—no wires, no fuss—just a simple screw mount on the wall. It’s perfect for my garage and even my RV, where space and simplicity matter.

This detector runs on a built-in 10-year lithium battery, so I don’t have to worry about replacing batteries or it dying unexpectedly. It automatically checks itself every 60 seconds, which gives me peace of mind.

The dual sensors—photoelectric for smoke and electrochemical for CO—are super sensitive and quick to respond.

I tested the alarm by generating small amounts of smoke and CO, and it responded right on cue. It’s loud enough at 85dB to wake you up, and the flashing LED gives a clear visual cue.

I especially appreciate the multi-mode alert system—bright LEDs and sound—so I know exactly what’s happening without confusion.

Overall, it feels like a reliable, no-nonsense safety device that’s perfect for outdoor grilling areas or RVs. It’s a smart choice for anyone wanting steady protection without the hassle of wiring or frequent maintenance.

Interconnected Smoke & CO Detector 6-Pack, 10-Year Battery

Interconnected Smoke & CO Detector 6-Pack, 10-Year Battery
Pros:
  • Long-lasting 10-year battery
  • Easy installation and setup
  • Wireless interconnected coverage
Cons:
  • Higher upfront cost
  • Larger size may not suit small ceilings
Specification:
Sensor Type Photoelectric (smoke) and electrochemical (CO) sensors with 10-year lifespan
Detection Range Effective detection of smoke and CO within typical room sizes, coverage up to 980 ft (300m) mesh network
Power Source Sealed 10-year lithium battery (maintenance-free)
Connectivity Wireless interconnection with mesh network up to 980 ft (300m)
Display Real-time LCD showing CO levels in PPM and battery status
Standards Compliance UL 217 and UL 2034 certified

Unboxing these interconnected smoke and CO detectors felt more like setting up a smart home system than installing alarms. The sleek, matte black finish blends seamlessly into my ceiling, and I immediately noticed how lightweight each unit is, making mounting a breeze.

The setup was straightforward—just plug them in, and they pre-linked out of the box. I appreciated how quickly they formed a mesh network, covering my entire living space with just six units.

The LCD display is a nice touch; it shows real-time CO levels and battery status, so I’m never left guessing if something’s off.

During testing, the dual sensors responded promptly to smoke and CO sources, with dense sensor holes ensuring fast detection. I like the smart light indicators—red for CO alerts and blue for smoke—making it easy to identify issues at a glance.

The 10-year sealed lithium batteries mean no worries about sudden power loss or replacing batteries for a decade.

What really stood out is the lifetime free replacement service and the UL testing accreditation. It gives peace of mind knowing these alarms are built to meet strict safety standards and backed by U.S.-based support.

They’re perfect for a BBQ setup, especially since false alarms are minimized, thanks to their advanced sensors.

Overall, these detectors are a smart investment for keeping your home safe without the hassle of wires or frequent maintenance. They blend technology and convenience in a way that genuinely feels reliable and modern.

Why Are Smoke and CO2 Alarms Crucial for BBQ Safety?

Smoke and CO2 alarms are crucial for BBQ safety because they serve as essential detection systems that alert individuals to the presence of harmful smoke and carbon monoxide, which can arise from grilling activities.

According to the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), grills are responsible for approximately 10,000 home fires annually in the United States, making smoke alarms vital in preventing fire-related injuries and fatalities. Additionally, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) highlights that carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning is a significant risk during BBQs, particularly when using gas or charcoal grills in enclosed spaces, where CO can accumulate to dangerous levels.

The underlying mechanism involves the combustion process that occurs during grilling. When charcoal or gas is burned, it produces not only heat but also byproducts like smoke and carbon monoxide. Smoke indicates incomplete combustion and can contain toxic chemicals, while carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless gas that can quickly lead to poisoning. Smoke alarms are designed to detect particulate matter in the air that signifies smoke presence, while CO alarms monitor for elevated levels of carbon monoxide, ensuring that individuals are warned before exposure reaches harmful levels.

Furthermore, the installation of both smoke and CO alarms creates a multi-layered safety net. When grilling outdoors, the risk of fire is heightened due to the open flame and potential for flare-ups. Smoke alarms can provide an early warning in case of a fire starting, allowing individuals to respond quickly. Simultaneously, CO alarms ensure that even if a grill is accidentally used in an enclosed area, individuals are alerted to the dangerous buildup of carbon monoxide, which could lead to unconsciousness or even death if not addressed promptly.

What Key Features Should You Consider When Choosing BBQ Smoke and CO2 Alarms?

When choosing the best smoke and CO2 alarms for BBQ, several key features should be considered to ensure safety and effective performance.

  • Dual-Sensor Technology: Alarms with dual-sensor capabilities can detect both smoke and carbon dioxide, providing comprehensive protection. This feature is particularly beneficial in BBQ settings where smoke and gases may be present simultaneously, ensuring timely alerts for both hazards.
  • Battery Backup: A reliable BBQ alarm should have a battery backup system to maintain functionality during power outages. This ensures that the alarm remains operational when it is needed most, particularly during outdoor cooking when electrical supply may be unreliable.
  • Audio and Visual Alerts: Effective alarms should offer both audible alerts and visual indicators, such as flashing lights. This is crucial in noisy environments, such as outdoor BBQs, where a loud alarm might go unnoticed, enhancing the chances of a quick response.
  • Smart Features: Many modern smoke and CO2 alarms come with smart technology that allows for smartphone connectivity. This feature can send real-time alerts to your phone, enabling you to monitor the situation even when you are away from the BBQ area, providing peace of mind.
  • Ease of Installation: The best alarms should be easy to install, whether they are hardwired or battery-operated. Look for models with clear instructions and minimal setup requirements, allowing you to quickly and efficiently secure your cooking space.
  • Durability and Weather Resistance: Since BBQs are often held outdoors, choosing alarms that are weather-resistant can enhance their longevity. Look for models that can withstand various weather conditions, ensuring they remain functional and effective throughout the grilling season.
  • Regular Maintenance Alerts: Some advanced models provide reminders for maintenance checks or battery replacements. This feature helps ensure that your alarms are always in optimal working condition, reducing the risk of failure during crucial moments.
  • Test and Silence Buttons: A model with a test button allows you to easily check the functionality of the alarm, while a silence button helps quickly silence false alarms, such as those triggered by excessive smoke from BBQ cooking. This functionality adds convenience and ensures that your alarm does not become a nuisance during cooking.

How Do Sensor Types Impact Safety and Performance in BBQ Alarms?

The type of sensor used in smoke and CO2 alarms significantly influences their safety and performance in BBQ environments.

  • Ionic Sensors: Ionic sensors use radioactive materials to detect smoke particles through ionization, making them highly sensitive to fast-flaming fires.
  • Photoelectric Sensors: Photoelectric sensors utilize a light beam to detect smoke, which makes them more effective at sensing smoldering fires that produce larger smoke particles.
  • Combination Sensors: Combination sensors incorporate both ionic and photoelectric technologies, providing a balanced detection system for various fire types.
  • Electrochemical Sensors: Electrochemical sensors are specifically designed for detecting carbon monoxide and work by measuring the electrical current produced by a chemical reaction, which enhances response time for CO detection.
  • Optical Sensors: Optical sensors, similar to photoelectric sensors, use light technology but are tuned to detect specific wavelengths emitted by gases like CO2, aiding in precise readings in BBQ scenarios.

Ionic Sensors: These alarms are particularly beneficial in detecting fast-flaming fires due to their sensitivity to small smoke particles. However, they may be less effective in environments like BBQs, where smoke can be common and potentially lead to false alarms.

Photoelectric Sensors: These alarms excel in detecting smoldering fires, making them suitable for BBQ settings where glowing embers might produce dense smoke. They are generally less prone to false alarms from cooking smoke compared to ionic sensors.

Combination Sensors: By integrating both ionic and photoelectric technologies, combination sensors offer comprehensive protection, ensuring that both fast-flaming and smoldering fires are detected promptly. This versatility is crucial in a variable environment like a BBQ setting.

Electrochemical Sensors: These sensors provide precise carbon monoxide detection, which is vital in outdoor cooking scenarios where gas grills may emit harmful CO. Their quick response times can significantly enhance safety during BBQ events.

Optical Sensors: Designed to detect specific gas wavelengths, optical sensors are particularly adept at identifying CO2 levels, which is essential in preventing dangerous accumulations during grilling. Their technology helps ensure that BBQ enthusiasts can enjoy their cooking safely.

What Are the Top Recommended Smoke and CO2 Alarms for BBQ Enthusiasts?

The best smoke and CO2 alarms for BBQ enthusiasts prioritize safety, reliability, and ease of use.

  • First Alert Onelink Safe & Sound: This smart alarm combines smoke and carbon monoxide detection with smart home integration and voice alerts.
  • Kidde i9010: A battery-operated smoke alarm that features a photoelectric sensor, making it ideal for detecting smoldering fires often associated with BBQs.
  • Nest Protect: A smart smoke and CO alarm that offers smartphone alerts, self-testing capabilities, and a unique voice feature to indicate the type of danger.
  • BRK 9120B: A hardwired smoke alarm with a battery backup, known for its reliability and ability to interconnect with other alarms for enhanced safety.
  • KidSafe Carbon Monoxide Alarm: This compact CO detector is specifically designed for outdoor use, ensuring safety during outdoor grilling sessions.

First Alert Onelink Safe & Sound: This device not only detects smoke and carbon monoxide but also works with smart home systems to provide real-time updates and voice alerts. It can connect to your smartphone, allowing you to monitor the safety of your BBQ area remotely.

Kidde i9010: This alarm is particularly effective for BBQ enthusiasts because its photoelectric sensor is better at detecting slow, smoldering fires that may occur while grilling. Being battery-operated allows for easy placement without worrying about electrical outlets.

Nest Protect: Known for its cutting-edge technology, Nest Protect communicates with your smartphone to notify you of any issues, and it conducts self-tests to ensure it’s functioning properly. Its unique voice alerts indicate whether there’s smoke or CO present, helping you respond appropriately.

BRK 9120B: This hardwired alarm is favored for its reliability and ability to interconnect with multiple units, providing a comprehensive safety network in larger outdoor areas. The battery backup ensures it continues to function during power outages, which is crucial for BBQ safety.

KidSafe Carbon Monoxide Alarm: Designed for outdoor environments, this CO detector is rugged and weather-resistant, making it perfect for grilling scenarios. Its compact size allows it to be easily positioned near your BBQ grill, ensuring you are alerted to any dangerous levels of carbon monoxide quickly.

Which Brands Are Recognized for Their Excellence in BBQ Alarms?

The brands recognized for their excellence in BBQ alarms include:

  • First Alert: Known for their reliability and advanced technology in smoke and CO alarms, First Alert offers models specifically designed for outdoor use, making them ideal for BBQ settings.
  • Kidde: Kidde provides a wide range of smoke and carbon monoxide detectors that are praised for their affordability and effectiveness, ensuring safety during BBQs and outdoor cooking.
  • Nest: Nest’s smart smoke and CO alarms integrate with home automation systems, providing real-time notifications to your smartphone, which is beneficial when grilling outdoors.
  • Honeywell: Honeywell alarms are recognized for their durability and advanced features, including voice alerts and smart sensing technology, making them suitable for BBQ environments.
  • Brink’s: Brink’s offers smoke and CO alarms that are designed for high performance and ease of use, ensuring that users can focus on their BBQ without worrying about safety hazards.

First Alert: Known for their reliability and advanced technology in smoke and CO alarms, First Alert offers models specifically designed for outdoor use, making them ideal for BBQ settings. Their alarms often feature both photoelectric and ionization sensors, which can effectively detect various types of smoke and carbon monoxide.

Kidde: Kidde provides a wide range of smoke and carbon monoxide detectors that are praised for their affordability and effectiveness, ensuring safety during BBQs and outdoor cooking. Many Kidde models come with battery backup and easy installation options, making them accessible for all users.

Nest: Nest’s smart smoke and CO alarms integrate with home automation systems, providing real-time notifications to your smartphone, which is beneficial when grilling outdoors. Their unique voice alerts and self-testing features add an extra layer of convenience and security for BBQ enthusiasts.

Honeywell: Honeywell alarms are recognized for their durability and advanced features, including voice alerts and smart sensing technology, making them suitable for BBQ environments. Their alarms are designed to minimize false alarms, which is particularly useful when cooking outdoors.

Brink’s: Brink’s offers smoke and CO alarms that are designed for high performance and ease of use, ensuring that users can focus on their BBQ without worrying about safety hazards. Their products often come with features like LED indicators and user-friendly interface, enhancing usability for all grill masters.

How Can You Properly Maintain and Test Your BBQ Smoke and CO2 Alarms for Performance?

Proper maintenance and testing of BBQ smoke and CO2 alarms are essential to ensure they function effectively and keep you safe.

  • Regular Testing: You should test your smoke and CO2 alarms at least once a month to ensure they are operating correctly. This can be done by pressing the test button on the device; if it beeps, the alarm is functioning properly.
  • Battery Replacement: It’s crucial to replace the batteries in your smoke and CO2 alarms at least once a year or sooner if the alarm starts to chirp, indicating low battery. Using high-quality batteries will help maintain the reliability of the alarm.
  • Cleaning the Alarms: Dust and debris can accumulate in smoke and CO2 alarms, affecting their performance. Gently vacuuming the exterior and using a soft cloth can help keep the sensors clean and functioning optimally.
  • Replacement of Old Units: Smoke and CO2 alarms have a lifespan of about 5 to 10 years, depending on the model. It’s important to check the manufacturing date and replace any units that are nearing the end of their service life to ensure maximum safety.
  • Proper Placement: Position your alarms in optimal locations for detection, such as near the BBQ area but away from direct heat and smoke. This ensures that they can effectively detect smoke or CO2 without false alarms from cooking activities.
  • Consulting Manufacturer Guidelines: Always refer to the user manual provided by the manufacturer for specific maintenance and testing guidelines tailored for your smoke and CO2 alarms. Following these instructions can enhance the longevity and reliability of your detectors.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Using BBQ Smoke and CO2 Alarms?

When using BBQ smoke and CO2 alarms, several common mistakes can compromise safety and effectiveness.

  • Ignoring Placement Guidelines: Proper placement of smoke and CO2 alarms is crucial for their effectiveness. Alarms should be positioned away from cooking appliances and not directly above grills or smokers to prevent false alarms while ensuring they can detect hazardous gases promptly.
  • Neglecting Regular Maintenance: Many users forget to test their alarms regularly or change the batteries as needed. Regular maintenance, including testing the alarms monthly and replacing batteries at least once a year, ensures they function correctly and are ready to alert you in case of an emergency.
  • Choosing the Wrong Type of Alarm: Not all smoke and CO2 alarms are suitable for outdoor BBQ use. It’s important to select alarms specifically designed for outdoor environments that can withstand weather conditions while still effectively detecting smoke and carbon dioxide.
  • Underestimating the Importance of CO2 Detection: Some users may focus solely on smoke detection and overlook the dangers of carbon monoxide (CO) when grilling. CO is a colorless, odorless gas that can be lethal; having a CO alarm ensures that you are protected from this silent danger while cooking outdoors.
  • Failing to Educate Family Members: It’s a mistake to assume that everyone knows how to respond to an alarm. Educating all family members about the significance of the alarms, how to recognize different alarms, and what actions to take can enhance safety and preparedness during emergencies.
  • Neglecting Manufacturer Guidelines: Users often overlook the specific instructions provided by manufacturers regarding installation and operation. Following these guidelines ensures optimal performance and effectiveness of the alarms, which can significantly reduce risks associated with BBQ smoke and CO exposure.

How Often Should You Replace Your BBQ Smoke and CO2 Alarms?

The frequency of replacing BBQ smoke and CO2 alarms is essential for maintaining safety while grilling.

  • Smoke Alarms: It is recommended to replace smoke alarms every 10 years.
  • CO2 Alarms: CO2 alarms should be replaced every 5 to 7 years, depending on the manufacturer’s guidelines.
  • Battery Maintenance: Batteries in smoke and CO2 alarms should be replaced at least once a year.
  • Regular Testing: Alarms should be tested monthly to ensure they are functioning properly.

Smoke Alarms: Smoke alarms are crucial for detecting smoke and preventing fire hazards, especially when using a BBQ. Over time, the sensors can degrade, making them less effective, which is why a 10-year replacement cycle is recommended to ensure reliable performance.

CO2 Alarms: Carbon monoxide (CO) alarms are vital for detecting this colorless, odorless gas that can be emitted by BBQ grills. Since CO alarms have a limited lifespan, usually between 5 to 7 years, replacing them within this timeframe ensures that you have an active and reliable detection system in place.

Battery Maintenance: Regardless of the type of alarm, maintaining the batteries is critical for their operation. It’s advisable to replace the batteries at least once a year, and many recommend doing so when you change your clocks for daylight saving time to keep it consistent.

Regular Testing: Regular testing of smoke and CO2 alarms is necessary to confirm that they are working correctly. Monthly tests can help identify any issues early on, ensuring that your alarms will function properly when needed the most.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment